Two weeks later, Carmella received her rematch against Flair but was unsuccessful in regaining the title.
Carmella Aligns With R-Truth
In September 2018, Carmella turned face and agreed to manage R-Truth for his match with The Miz. Carmella then started managing Truth and the two were announced as tag team partners for the upcoming season two of Mixed Match Challenge. They called themselves, “The Fabulous Truth.”
In November 2018, Carmella took part in Survivor Series as part of Team SmackDown. She went on to eliminate Tamina before being eliminated by Bayley. At the Mixed Match Challenge, Carmella and Truth lost the first three matches before defeating Rusev and Lana to qualify for the playoffs. They went on to defeat Jeff Hardy and Charlotte Flair in the quarter-finals and previous winners The Miz and Asuka in the semi-finals. In the finals of the Mixed Match Challenge that took place at the TLC pay-per-view, Carmella and Truth defeated Jinder Mahal and Alicia Fox. As a result, this earned both superstars the number 30 spots for their respective Royal Rumble matches at Royal Rumble 2019.
Carmella participated in the Royal Rumble 2019 match, but was eliminated by Charlotte Flair. That February, Carmella started teaming with Naomi. They took part in a six-team Elimination Chamber match for the inaugural WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship. Naomi and Carmella were the first team eliminated.
Carmella Wins the Women’s Battle Royal
At WrestleMania 35, Carmella won the WrestleMania Women’s Battle Royal after last eliminating Sarah Logan. She then took part in the Money in the Bank ladder match at the namesake pay-per-view. Carmella injured her knee at Money in the Bank and was unsuccessful in winning the match. Her “knee injury” was used to spark a feud with Fire and Desire (Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville), which ended abruptly because she continued to manage R-Truth. She would help him escape and defend the title against various competitors.
Carmella Wins 24/7 Title
On the September 23rd episode of RAW, Carmella rolled-up on R-Truth to capture the 24/7 Championship from him. Her title reign came to an end 11 days later, during SmackDown’s 20th Anniversary on October 4, when she was pinned by Marshmello backstage.
Later that night, Carmella regained the title from Marshmello. During the Hell in a Cell pay-per-view, Tamina pinned Carmella to end her second reign with the title at only 2 days. A few minutes later, Carmella helped Truth defeat Tamina to win the 24/7 Championship again.
The alliance between Carmella and R-Truth was ended abruptly when Truth was drafted to the RAW brand and Carmella remained on SmackDown. On the November 8th episode of SmackDown, Carmella and Dana Brooke defeated Fire and Desire to qualify as part of Team SmackDown at Survivor Series. At the event, they lost to Team NXT at the event.
Carmella participated in the Women’s Royal Rumble 2020 match entering at number 27. She lasted a little over six minutes in the match but was eliminated by Shayna Baszler. In the next few months, Carmella defeated several superstars including Sonya Deville and Mandy Rose. These wins earned her a title match for the SmackDown Women’s Championship against Bayley but was unsuccessful.
Carmella then aligned herself with Dana Brooke and together they challenged Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross for the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship, but they were unsuccessful in capturing the titles. She participated in her third ever Money in the Bank ladder match at the Money in the Bank pay-per-view, but she failed to win the briefcase.
Carmella the Untouchable
In September 2020, WWE began airing vignettes on SmackDown hyping the arrival of a mystery woman. Six weeks later, on the October 2nd episode, Carmella revealed that she was the mystery woman. She then began using the new mantra of “Untouchable,” along with a new theme song.
After a five month hiatus, Carmella made her return appearance on on the November 6 episode. She attacked Sasha Banks following her title defense against Bayley, thus turning heel for the first time since 2018. Towards the end of 2020, Carmella and Bayley continued to cut promos and attack each other. This eventually led to a match for the SmackDown Women’s Championship at the TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs event. At the event, on December 20, Carmella faced Sasha Banks but lost.
Carmella teamed with Billie Kay at WrestleMania 37 to participate in a tag team turmoil match to determine the number one contenders for the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship against Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler. Carmella and Billie Kay were unsuccessful in the match. She then faced both members of the Riott Squad individually, and beat them both. She then proclaimed herself “The Most Beautiful Woman in All of WWE.”
Carmella Fights for the SmackDown Women’s Championship
Carmella would then have three opportunities for the SmackDown Women’s Championship against Bianca Belair. The first was on the July 16 episode of SmackDown, one on the July 23 episode, and one at a house show in Louisville, Kentucky. Carmella was unsuccessful at all three opportunities. She was then scheduled to be Sasha Banks’ replacement for SummerSlam against Bianca Belair, but was then attacked by a returning Becky Lynch.
Carmella lost to Liv Morgan at the Extreme Rules kickoff show. As part of the 2021 Draft, Carmella was drafted to the WWE’s RAW brand.
After Crown Jewel, Carmella and Queen Zelina began appearing together as a tag team. On the November 22nd episode of RAW, Queen Zelina and Carmella successfully won the Women’s Tag Team Championships when they defeated Nikki A.S.H. and Rhea Ripley.
At WrestleMania 38, Carmella and Queen Zelina lost the titles in a fatal 4-way match to Sasha Banks and Naomi. The other teams that participated in the cyclonic match included Shayna Baszler & Natalya as well as Rhea Ripley with Liv Morgan. The following night on RAW, Zelina blamed Carmella for their loss at WrestleMania. This led to Zelina attacking Carmella, thus ending their alliance. Carmella suffered an injury during a live event on August 6.
Carmella Returns to In-Ring Action
Carmella returned on the January 30, 2023 episode of RAW as a face with her previous gimmick which she used until 2020. The following week on RAW, Carmella defeated Candice LeRae, Mia Yim, and Piper Niven in a fatal four-way match to qualify for the women’s Elimination Chamber match at the namesake pay-per-view. At the event, Carmella failed to win the match after she was last pinned by Asuka.
SHOW LESS
